Tragedy in Chatham: Car Crashes Into After-School Program, Killing Four Including Three Children

 

 

CHATHAM, IL — April 30, 2025 — A quiet and routine Monday afternoon turned into a scene of unimaginable devastation in the close-knit community of Chatham, Illinois, when a vehicle veered off the road and slammed into a building housing an after-school program. The violent crash resulted in the deaths of four individuals, including three young children and a teenage camp counselor, sending shockwaves through the town and leaving families in deep mourning.

The incident occurred around 3:35 p.m. on Monday, April 28, 2025, as children participated in various activities inside the building operated by a local youth center on the 500 block of East Walnut Street. According to early reports from the Chatham Police Department and Sangamon County Sheriff’s Office, a vehicle traveling at a high rate of speed lost control, left the roadway, and smashed through the front of the building, causing a partial collapse and widespread chaos.

Emergency crews responded swiftly to the scene, where they encountered what they described as a “catastrophic and heartbreaking” situation. Despite their efforts, four lives were lost in the crash:

• Rylee Britton, 18, a beloved youth mentor and after-school camp counselor known for her bright spirit and dedication to the children she served.
• Alma Buhnerkempe, 7, a cheerful and curious child who loved art and animals.
• Kathryn Corley, 7, remembered by teachers and classmates as gentle and kind.
• Ainsley Johnson, 8, a bright and energetic young girl who dreamed of being a teacher one day.

Several other children and staff members were injured in the crash and were transported to local hospitals for treatment. At least two children remain in critical condition, according to officials at Memorial Medical Center in Springfield.

Authorities have not yet released the identity of the driver, but sources close to the investigation confirmed that the individual survived the crash and is currently in custody. Investigators are looking into whether speed, impairment, or a medical emergency may have been contributing factors. The Illinois State Police Accident Reconstruction Unit is leading the investigation, with assistance from local agencies.

Witnesses described the terrifying moments leading up to the impact. “It sounded like an explosion,” said parent Tiffany Reynolds, who was arriving to pick up her son when the crash occurred. “I saw the car flying off the road and then heard the screaming. I’ll never forget it.”

The building, which had served for over a decade as a trusted space for after-school care and enrichment activities, was severely damaged in the crash. Community leaders say it will take time to assess whether the facility can be salvaged.

In the wake of the tragedy, the entire Chatham community has come together in mourning. Vigils were held Tuesday night, with hundreds gathering to light candles, pray, and support the grieving families. Floral tributes, stuffed animals, and handwritten messages have been placed outside the site of the accident.

Chatham Mayor Jennifer Douglas addressed the public with tears in her eyes. “There are no words for the grief we feel today,” she said. “We lost four beautiful souls—three precious children and a young woman who dedicated her life to serving them. Our hearts are shattered, and we are standing with every family affected.”

Local schools, including Ball Elementary and Glenwood Intermediate, have brought in grief counselors and crisis response teams to help students and staff cope with the emotional impact. The Chatham School District has announced a memorial day next week to honor the young lives lost.

Rylee Britton’s family released a statement remembering her as “a fierce advocate for kids and a natural leader who brought light into every room she entered.” Rylee had been planning to attend Illinois State University in the fall to study early childhood education.

Friends of Alma, Kathryn, and Ainsley say the girls were inseparable at camp and were often seen giggling together in the reading corner or helping younger children with activities. “They were sunshine,” said one teacher. “They really were.”

As the investigation continues and the community begins the long road to healing, fundraising efforts have been launched to support the victims’ families with funeral expenses, medical bills, and rebuilding efforts. Local churches and businesses have pledged support, and donations have poured in from neighboring towns.

Anyone with information about the crash is encouraged to contact the Chatham Police Department at (217) 483-2456.

This tragic incident has left an indelible mark on Chatham. As residents gather to mourn and remember those who were lost, one thing remains clear: this community will not forget the children and young woman taken far too soon.