Widespread Search Underway for Missing Manhattan School Administrator Mark Boehrer, 56, Last Seen in Hicksville, NY

 

 

HICKSVILLE, NY — April 30, 2025

A sense of urgency and deep concern has engulfed both Long Island and New York City following the unsettling disappearance of Mark Boehrer, a 56-year-old human resources director at the elite Brearley School in Manhattan. Boehrer was reported missing earlier this week after failing to return home from a routine weekend visit to Hicksville, a normally peaceful Nassau County suburb. The circumstances surrounding his disappearance have left authorities, loved ones, and his professional community on high alert.

According to law enforcement, Boehrer was last seen around 9:30 a.m. on Saturday, April 26, near Broadway Mall in Hicksville. He had reportedly traveled to Long Island to visit relatives but never arrived. His vehicle, a silver 2019 Subaru Outback, was later discovered abandoned in a nearby commuter lot off Route 106, with no signs of struggle or foul play immediately visible.

Authorities from the Nassau County Police Department have since launched an intensive investigation, collaborating with the NYPD, New York State Police, and other regional agencies. A Silver Alert has been issued, and search teams, including K-9 units and drones, have been canvassing the surrounding area.

Family and Community Plead for Help

“We are absolutely devastated and terrified,” said Laura Boehrer, Mark’s wife of 28 years, in a tearful statement on Tuesday. “Mark is the most responsible, kind-hearted person I know. For him to disappear like this—it’s not like him at all. We’re begging anyone who might have seen something, anything, to come forward.”

Friends and neighbors have described Boehrer as a warm, intelligent, and deeply dependable individual who has spent over a decade supporting staff and students at the Brearley School. Colleagues from the all-girls private school, located on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, expressed shock at his disappearance.

“Mark is not just our HR director—he’s a friend to everyone on staff,” said a faculty member who wished to remain anonymous. “He’s someone you can count on, and it’s just unthinkable that he would vanish without a trace.”

Timeline of Disappearance

Investigators have pieced together the following timeline:

• Friday, April 25: Boehrer left his Manhattan apartment in the evening, reportedly heading to visit relatives in Hicksville.
• Saturday, April 26, 9:30 a.m.: Surveillance footage captured Boehrer in the parking lot of Broadway Mall. He appeared to be alone and did not seem distressed.
• Later that day: Boehrer failed to show up at his intended destination, prompting concerned relatives to contact authorities.
• Sunday, April 27: His vehicle was found locked and unoccupied. No personal items were left behind.

Authorities are reviewing additional security footage, traffic cameras, and digital evidence, including cellphone and bank records. So far, no recent financial transactions or phone activity have been detected since the morning he was last seen.

Online Awareness and Support Grow

The missing persons case has quickly gained traction online, with the page Mark Boehrer Missing – New York serving as a central hub for updates, community outreach, and tips. The page includes photos of Mark, descriptions of his clothing on the day he vanished (a navy windbreaker, khakis, and brown loafers), and a number to call for tips.

The hashtag #FindMarkBoehrer has gained momentum across social media platforms, as users throughout New York and beyond amplify the family’s plea for answers.

Police Request Public Assistance

Nassau County Police have reiterated the importance of public cooperation in missing persons cases and are asking anyone who may have seen Boehrer or his vehicle between Friday evening and Saturday afternoon to contact them immediately. Even minor details could help piece together his whereabouts.

“We are treating this case with the utmost seriousness,” said Detective Lt. Richard Marino of the Missing Persons Unit. “We urge the public to remain vigilant, especially in the Hicksville and greater Long Island area.”

Anyone with information is asked to contact the Nassau County Police Missing Persons Squad at 516-573-7347 or 911 in an emergency. Tips may be made anonymously.

A Community Holds Its Breath

As the search enters its fifth day, hope remains that Mark Boehrer will be found safe and that answers will come to light. Vigils and prayer services are being organized in both Manhattan and Hicksville, as loved ones cling to hope and a community stands together in solidarity.

“We are not giving up,” said Boehrer’s daughter, Emily, in an emotional video message. “If you know anything—please, please speak up. We just want our dad home.”